+ Create new tricision Login 

Login

or


Forgot password?

First visit? Sign-up now!

By continuing you accept the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

time is up

Week #4 Discussion #1 (08/21 Class)

Your initial discussion thread is due on Day 3 (Thursday). Your grade will reflect both the quality of your initial post and the depth of your responses. Refer to the Discussion Forum Grading Rubric under the Settings icon above for guidance on how your discussion will be evaluated.

  A Carbon-Neutral Community Plan for Ashfordton
Imagine that you are a resident of Ashfordton, a community whose characteristics are described below. You have come together with your neighbors for a special meeting to devise a plan for helping the community become carbon-neutral by 2050, meaning that by that time, no net carbon dioxide emissions will be produced by residents as a whole.

Fortunately, you have all showed up to the meeting with lots of knowledge you gained from last week’s class discussion. Now it is time to put your thinking cap on and get to work! Your plan should consist of the following elements:

Energy conservation measures (e.g., promoting carpooling by adding special lanes to local highways) and
Steps to move toward sustainable energy production (e.g., installing solar panels on town government buildings)
Reducing energy consumption will help, but some actions will have to involve switching to other power sources for buildings and vehicles as well.

This week’s discussion will take place in an online app called “Tricider.” There, you will be able to post your ideas for plan components, and also share pros and cons of different proposals during the week. Finally, you will be able to vote on what you think should be in the plan.

For directions on how to use the Tricider app, please review the linked Help Guide. In Tricider, you will be expected to do the following:

Post at least two separate and unique ideas. Include your full name for each one.
Post at least six different pros and cons for your classmates’ proposed ideas.
Vote on what you feel are the top three ideas in the list. (Do not vote before Friday.)
Please note: You are welcome to post questions and comments to this board for this instructor; however, this discussion board does not have any posting requirements of its own, and no additional credit will be given for posts made here.

Below, the Instructor will post both

The Ashfordton description you will be using for this activity and
The link you will be using to access Tricider for the activities below.
Ashfordton:

 

Population:                          32,000

Avg. High Temp (Dec):      34oF

Avg. High Temp (June):    62oF

Annual Precipitation:        62 in.

Urban Area:                      14 sq. mi.

Main Power Source:          natural gas

Overview:

The community of Ashfordton is located near sea level at the base of a snow-capped mountain, on a secluded ocean inlet, surrounded by rugged, forested land.  The only access to the city is by ferry or plane; no roads connect it to other communities in the region. Winters are wet, mild, and long. The city serves as the capital for the state of New Bridgepoint.  As such, government agencies are its leading employer, though tourism is also a major source of income, followed by commercial fishing.  The city is renowned for its scenic beauty; tall mountains capped by glaciers can be seen from the downtown. 


saved
Ideas
Pros and cons
 
Votes
Electril Car pool depots around town
by Mark Frantz
 
This is great because you can plan the carpool around who is going where at what time and everyon... more
by Amanda Smith
 
this is a great idea because you get to reduce emissions and to top it off it is an electric sour... more
by Alexandria Borjon
1
 
Transportation is the largest part of the average of the carbon dioxide emissions. Even though yo... more
 
I forgot to add my name to my post... Transportation is the largest part of the average of the ca... more
by Amy Pitzer
 
electric car pools like buses or a trolley would definitely benefit not only the amount of carbon... more
by jessica holland
 
Amazing idea! This is great all around for the environment and economy.
by Dalanais Serna
 
This would reduce the amount emissions in two ways, one by reducing the amount of vehicles on the... more
by Reannen Purser
 
7

Jessica Holland, Amy Pitzer, Sarah Golliher and 4 more

Tidal Power
by Dalanais Serna
Tidal power is growing rapidly in interest as countries look for ways to generate electricity wit... more
 
Good idea, this could be used to power an electric trolley and eliminate the need for planes.
by justin moore
 
Great Idea, since the town has a lot of wet land in surrounding areas.
by Mark Frantz
6

Jessica Holland, Reannen Purser, Amy Pitzer and 3 more

a local fishery and greenhouse could be built to reduce travel of food rid the need of commercial fishing.
by Justin Moore
 
I think this is a great idea! The community could even harvest gardens and really become more ind... more
 
I forgot to add my name to my post....I think this is a great idea! The community could even harv... more
by Amy Pitzer
 
Local fishery possibly a good idea, I think it might cause problems if not managed correctly.
by Mark Frantz
 
I love this idea. Great for Ashfordton, reducing travel, reduces the carbon footprint. Also fresh... more
by Dalanais Serna
 
This idea sounds like a wonderful way to employ aquaponics in the region! By combing greenhouse ... more
by Reannen Purser
 
This is a good idea because one we will create jobs, then we will not need commercial fishing whi... more
by Amanda Smith
4

Reannen Purser, Justin Moore, Dalanais Serna and 1 more

Conserving Energy- lighting
by Dalanais Serna
A way to conserve energy is to reduce lighting in your home or workplace. For example lighting... more
 
This will definitely help but, I think an incentive would be needed to have the local populace jo... more
by justin moore
 
this seems like a great start to an idea but it may take some revisons to it since houses are alr... more
by Alexandria Borjon
 
My apologies that post was for the one above you. This one is for your post... Reducing lighti... more
by Alexandria Borjon
 
Conserving energy with lighting is huge. As far as using natural sunlight or solar, our winters a... more
by Amy Pitzer
 
Electricity conservation is a good, and easy first step! Another way to conserve energy through ... more
by Reannen Purser
 
This is okay but we need better options and better choices for the residents of this town.
by Amanda Smith
1
Justin Moore
There should be a nonprofit recycling place for old clothes to make into insulation for homes. Each home should be required by the city to have a certain amount of insulation. The recycled insulation will be available much cheaper than any other kind and give a substantial tax break to the homeow... more
by Amy Pitzer
Home Insulation
 
this seems like a great start to an idea but it may take some revisons to it since houses are alr... more
by Alexandria Borjon
 
This is a great idea. But as Alexandria mentioned it would be difficult to install in the old hom... more
by Dalanais Serna
1
Amy Pitzer
Biomass Energy
by Reannen Purser
Biomass energy is a viable option for this community because of the forested land around it. Bio... more
 
Biomass energy is a natural part of the carbon cycle as opposed to fossil-based sources of fuel s... more
by Dalanais Serna
1
Dalanais Serna
Since the only means of transportation in and out of the town is by boat or plane, use community funds to invest in using Hydrogen-Powered boats/ferries. This would provide a means of transport from the community to the city as we substantially lesson the carbon emissions.
by Amy Pitzer
Hydro Powered Transportation
 
since gas is not the primary source of fuel less carbon dioxide would pollute the air
by Jessica Holland
 
hydrogen would provide some sort of waste in the air which would require more waste management
by Jessica Holland
1
Alexandria Borjon
I suggest that this town use hydropower for a source of energy sicen they are located near an ocean inlet. My second idea is that this town use a wind hydrogen system for its source of energy.
by Alexandria Borjon
 
Hydropower is a bad idea for this town because hydropower can cause some enviormental damage. Als... more
by Amanda Smith
 
I think hydro power is a great idea, however i would place it higher up the mountain and not clos... more
by justin moore
 
With there being snow on top of the mountain then there will be waterfalls nearby. Also since the... more
by Amy Pitzer
 
hydro power would be an excellent source of fuel for the boats that are used to transport residen... more
by Jessica Holland
 
I thought of this alternative for fossil fuel, but I did not believe it would be a good choice. I... more
by Dalanais Serna
 
The potential environmental damages from hydropower could negatively impact the tourist industry ... more
by Reannen Purser
0
Hydropower
by Reannen Purser
Hydropower is a viable option for this community due to the surrounding water ways, as well as th... more
0
the city should invest in using solar power and installing solar panels in at least government buildings and local businesses. another idea to reduce the production of carbon dioxide is to generate or provide a dealership that sells electric cars.
by Jessica Holland
by using solar energy, less carbon dioxide will be produced by certain businesses like restaurant... more
0
I propose that Ashforton transfers all energy sources from fossil fuels over to solar and wind renewable energy.
by Sarah Golliher
 
I think that the wind energy is a great idea, but I am afraid we are not that hot and what if we ... more
by Amanda Smith
 
I think the combination of the 2 will assist when the other is not producing.
by justin moore
 
The con about solar power here for this town is that there isn't a great deal of sun or heat base... more
by Alexandria Borjon
0
Instructions
by Bo Sosnicki
This week’s discussion will take place in an online app called “Tricider.” There, you will be... more
0
Energy Baselining
by Amanda Smith
This is a reference tool, this will allow us too compare the before and after changes in weather ... more
 
This is a necessary tool however it doe not help the current mission/plan.
by justin moore
0
Electric stoves instead of gas
by Sarah Golliher
 
Alternative types of electricity would have be established first and then we have to incentivize ... more
 
Alternative types of electricity would have be established first and then we have to incentivize ... more
by justin moore
 
With the community trying to conserve energy and lower emissions, this may not be the best soluti... more
by Amy Pitzer
 
as long as the extra energy comes from a renewable source that is not man made
by Jessica Holland
0
Electric Trolley
by Mark Frantz
 
This is a good idea. The only con I can think of is sometimes people don't want to wait for a tro... more
by Amanda Smith
 
The only issue with electric trolley is that this trolley can only be used in this town since the... more
by Alexandria Borjon
0
The addition of an electric cable trolley to and from the town would help eliminate emissions from planes flying to Ashordton.
by Justin Moore
 
you make a good point about electric trolleys but it will not eliminate the emissions from planes... more
by Alexandria Borjon
 
Electric trolleys within the township would be beneficial, however it is not beneficial for trans... more
by Reannen Purser
0
Wind Energy
by Amanda Smith
This is creating electricty through wind. Even though there may not be much wind we will still ge... more
 
You are correct that wind is a great resource to create electricity, but in the scenario of how t... more
 
I forgot to place my name on my post.... You are correct that wind is a great resource to create ... more
by Amy Pitzer
 
Wind energy is great alternative to fossil fuels, but I do not believe that it is a good idea for... more
by Dalanais Serna
 
The terrain in this area is not conducive to wind energy; as stated before wind farms require ext... more
by Reannen Purser
0

Comments

https://www.tricider.com/brainstorming/2aUJi0tdFRZ