What would you have done in the shoes of Antigone? Why?
saved
Ideas
Pros and cons
Votes
I think that if i were in the shoes of Antigone , probably i would act in the same way, because there are some values really important for us and for our country which have precedence over other. An other reason is the family bond and in my opinion it has an influence on natural laws.
by Martina L.
i agree completely.
by Michelle.me
1
I totally agree with your opinion. 'Cause I think that the family is for many people more importa...more
by Amina
1
I agree with you. Because the family is one of the important thing and nobody can forbid you to b...more
by Anastasia
1
I share your opinion too. I think that the family is very important for us and no matter what her...more
by laura
I agree with you too. I would do the same for my family and friends.
by Rolf
2
Vote
Jacqueline
Rolf
i think that our UNIVERSAL value are more important than the value of every different city because the Universal value make us egual and if there aren't them we might have more violence in the world than now becouse nobody will respect nobody... after that if i was antigone i may have done the sa...more
by Leonardo
add arguments if you do not agree so we will discuss about it.. :)
by Leonardo
3
I think that Antigone was right because there are values that are UNIVERSAL and no city can chang...more
by Lorenzo
On one hand I agree that there are universal values (the idea of universal human rights);
on th...more
by Anke W.
2
2
Vote
Giusi Gualtieri
Jacqueline
I would bury Polinice
by Giusi Gualtieri
Because more than a law of a man I believe in the laws of nature
i think you're right because a loto of storic people had fought for this fundamental reason
by Leonardo
you are right, in fact, we should follow the laws of the nature...but if all people break the law...more
by Filippo
1
i agree. in the debate on Antigone Sophocles we understood that natural laws dictated by heart pr...more
by Giulia S.
1
My opinion is that the man should follow the laws of the nature beaucuse they are more right than...more
by andrea
0
Vote
If i were in the shoes of Antigone, I would have buried my brother. I think we have to respect natural laws at first, because they are the laws that we need to live in peace and together.
by Benedetta
Yes, I´m totally agree with you, i think it will be the right process.
by Leah
1
Vote
Leah
If I were Antigone I would have done the same, because as my friends said before, the natural rules are more important than the laws of a single place. These natural values in fact are shared by people all over the world, while some laws are related only to some states.
by Giulia F.
1
Vote
Leah
i think i would have done the same thing that Antigone had done, because i think there are some value which are very important and which must be respected becouse they allow us to rub along in different countries and comunities .But we need to consider that there are also other laws called the ci...more
by tommaso
I am in your opinion, because we can not live in a city without any laws, but we have to respect ...more
by Julia
0
Vote
First i had thought that I wouldn't bury Polinice if I were Antigone because I had thought that he did it only to transgress the law. Later I changed my idea in fact I understood that Antigone bury Polinice to respect his brother and to give him a worthy burial. Indeed I hope in the existence of ...more
by Romina
The most important verse in Antigone is: I am not born to hate with other people, but to love wit...more
by Melpomeni Dimoulka
0
Vote
The laws have two different sides, sometimes they behave us and they protect us but sometimes they dont allow them to do what they want. Antigone reacted basing in her feelings override the law of Creon. So, in some cases people should listen to their hearts.
by Aspa, George, Zoi
0
Vote
I believe that Antigone was right.She followed the rules that were given from Gods.Antigone loved her brother so much and she risked her life for him.If i were Antigone,i would do the same thing.In my opinion the laws from Gods are more important than the laws that are given from people.We should...more
by Niki A.
0
Vote
If I were Antigone,i did not bury my brother because there is a law which forbid the burial and it has punishment.
by Anthia
0
Vote
Antigone respected not the local rules but a much more important rule:the natural one. I believe I would have done the same thing, because a brother is a brother and for him you are allowed to not respect a stupid law.....On the other hand in a society rules must be respected to live all in armon...more
by Riccardo
0
Vote
believe that there is the right of both the thoughts .. because on one hand it is right that we all have to abide by a law that we all share and which retains control over the community, do not lead to the company in a 'anarchy, but likewise I think the company should have small differences from ...more
by Manuel
0
Vote
If I were Antigone I would ignore the law and i would bury my brother Polinice, because i believe in the existence of superior law which overstepes human laws.
by martina stara
0
Vote
in my opinion an important value, which have just a few, is to be yourself.
by Giulia Sabatini
A value can be "being yourself" and that is the consistency in the things you believe in. you can...more
0
Vote
An other way
by Marlon
I think if I were in the shoes of Antigone, I would not act in the same way. She was stupid, to "...more
0
Vote
In the shoes of Antigone, I believe I would have done the same thing. I believe that before the relativistic laws we must respect our own values and we must fight for our right. A law that forbid you to bury one your relative is a terrible injustice which is against all the natural and universal ...more
by Irene
0
Vote
If I were Antigone, I surely would have done the same.
0
Vote
If I were Antigone, I surely would have done the same.
0
Vote
If I were Antigone, I surely would have done the same.
0
Vote
If I were in the shoes of Antigone, I would have done the same thing. I would have buried my brother, because I think that the values of a city aren't as important as our natural values. In fact sometimes the laws of the city doesn't respect the fundamental principles of the life; this isn't acc...more
by Jacopo R.
0
Vote
every one of us has his own values that respects and i think that for every one they are very important e we want to respect them and even if we believe in the laws of nature sometime if they go against or are different from our values we don't respect the law of nature and we follow our values ...more
